Building on the past

Author Roger Hunt and SPAB Chairman Iain Boyd explain the background to their new book, New Design for Old Buildings, which includes a foreword from Kevin McCloud.

When William Morris fathered the SPAB and published the Society’s seminal Manifesto with its emphasis on honesty to fabric and respect for the layers of history, he could little have imagined the trends in architecture and the pressures on the built environment in the UK over the following 140 years.

Features_new design cover

At the time, the SPAB’s founders were expressing a revolutionary philosophy. But, inevitably, as the Society has been in existence for so long, it is often assumed to be a ‘conservative’ body as well as a ‘conservation’ one and, consequently, many believe it is fundamentally opposed to new design, or prefers to see it ‘in keeping with the original building’.

In fact, the welcome extended to new design is there to be seen in the Manifesto and is echoed in the new SPAB Approach published with this issue of The SPAB Magazine. Our book New Design for Old Buildings aims to do justice and give depth to this wide-ranging topic, helping all who wrestle with how to adapt or extend old buildings in a way that creates something interesting and new while respecting their original fabric.

We were keen to address any misconception that the SPAB is ossified, only interested in the past and unwilling to embrace or allow change. Anyone who really knows the Society will be aware that this is untrue. When the SPAB, in its statutory role, does object to a proposed change to an old building, it does so with good reason and often suggests alternative solutions where new architecture is clearly of its time and readable as such.

3.35_One of the links between the British Museum and the World Conservation and Exhibition Centre

One of the links between the British Museum and the World Conservation and Exhibition Centre. Photo: Roger Hunt

Often the SPAB’s objections are simply to poor design that fails to take proper account of the existing building. In the case of an old building, new work must be seen as just one phase in a long timeline spanning decades, even centuries. Proposals that do not account for how the new will coexist with the old over time, or which do not allow for further change in decades to come, are likely to stumble at some point.

The SPAB position continues to be that good new architecture can complement an old building and that it is usually preferable to designing in imitation of an earlier style. This long-held precept is widely supported in the design and conservation community, although not by all. As authors of the book, we were only too aware that some may disagree with our arguments and ideas, insisting on seeing new design as a threat or an unwelcome intrusion. Many others, we were sure, would be pleasantly surprised.

Ch3_Martello Tower Y

Good new design has long been encouraged by the SPAB through its annual Philip Webb Award, which celebrates the sympathetic re-use of existing buildings and sensitive new design in a historic context. It is an opportunity for students and architects in the early stages of their career to demonstrate their grasp of repair techniques and their engagement with the SPAB’s principle of fitting the new to the old, as well as their design flair.

In writing New Design for Old Buildings we needed to illustrate this thinking and wanted to encourage people to be braver, whether architect, designer, contractor, building owner, conservation officer, planner or student – anyone who has an involvement with old buildings and who is faced with the challenges of adapting and using them in future decades.

Many examples of new design in a historic context have been described and celebrated in books and magazines, often featuring projects from North America and elsewhere in Europe. With New Design for Old Buildings we made the early decision to focus solely on buildings from the UK. At first we thought we might struggle to find sufficient good examples but quickly discovered a rich supply of exemplary schemes, both large and small, as well as countless designers and craftspeople who demonstrate a thoughtful and creative approach.

The diversity of approaches taken has been equally impressive with buildings spanning a period from medieval times to the second half of the twentieth century. They range from large schemes such as the British Museum’s World Conservation and Exhibitions Centre in London by Rogers Stirk Harbour + Partners to the simple but practical wooden extension to the beautiful Holy Trinity Church at Goodramgate in York, by simmonsherriff.

Holy Trinity Church, Goodramgate York, extension

Holy Trinity, Goodramgate, York. Photo: Kynan Simmons

The research was absorbing and we enjoyed personal tours of buildings as diverse as Astley Castle and the National Theatre. We were often guided by architects but also by the users of buildings who were often quickest to point out a scheme’s successes or peculiarities. On other occasions, capturing imagery was our mission’s aim and we came to appreciate previously unnoticed architectural details as we waited, camera on tripod, for the clouds to clear the sun, or the engrossed tourist to step out of frame in the peace of an ancient structure like Ely Cathedral.

We spent a great many hours with architects and others, including distinguished practitioners in the field as well as more recent talent, who have immersed themselves in the art of bringing the old and new together. From them we have gained fascinating and often personal insights into the thinking behind their schemes and the wider issues of conservation and new design.

As we gathered examples and spoke to more people, the message that well-executed and thoughtful new architecture can and does sit happily alongside old and is preferable to poor pastiche was reinforced. Schemes succeed when the relationship between new and old is well understood and skilfully managed. This is the core of the SPAB ethos: successful new design requires a deep understanding of what has gone before, as well as a vision of how the new and old parts will perform together long into the future.

Within the book we aim to provide an insight into the factors and considerations that go towards making a successful scheme. We do not presume to set out in depth the processes of design or the specifics of what design is – this understanding comes with long years of training and experience. Overall, we attempt to present the best philosophical and practical thinking on the subject. Rather than analysing a select few case studies, we draw on a larger sample, referencing over one hundred buildings; some appearing once within the book, others numerous times.

We attempt to analyse the processes involved in creating new design in the historic context and begin by charting the SPAB’s long experience in considering the relationship between conservation methods and the visual effect of new design when applied to buildings and sites in the historic environment. Our first chapter ‘Embracing Good Design’ looks at how its introduction into this context relies on understanding, respect, good manners and skill.

In the further chapters, we examine the starting points and the aspects of a project that need proper consideration to give the best chance of success. Later chapters explore the material palette that is available to designers, ranging from the use of those most traditional of building materials, lime and wood, right through to modern composites and weathered steel.

Examples are given throughout the book, and in particular within the two chapters focusing on forms of adaptation and interiors. While no single solution can be deployed wholesale to fix a problem elsewhere, we hope that enough are given in the course of the book to illustrate both the philosophy of approach and the wide range of design options that are available in terms of form and finish. No book on adaptation would be complete without looking at issues around sustainability and our final chapter examines how old buildings and new work can be ‘fit for the future’.

3.28__Astley Castle

The relationship of different materials at Astley Castle. Photo: Iain Boyd

Buildings result from collaborative effort and a creative vision shared between a number of people. Much of our focus is on the architects and designers who provide the vital narrative of imaginative thinking and execution. Architects understand that design is an overarching process that provides both a solution to an entire building brief and deals with more specific small scale detailing. But they cannot work without the efforts of others, the engineers, surveyors and contractors who make a scheme possible and of course a client who has had the vision to appoint a team that could bring sympathy, practicality and creativity to the scheme in the first place.

Inevitably a manuscript has to be handed to the publisher at a certain point, which is unfortunate as new and exciting schemes are emerging even as the book is going to print. This year’s Stirling Prize contenders include at least two schemes that could easily have been in the book, had they been completed earlier. It is important for the SPAB to continue to get its message across that good new design is welcome. We hope that those who read New Design for Old Buildings will be emboldened and gain a greater understanding that good new design is essential to ensuring the life and sustainability of old buildings.

Roger Hunt blogs at www.huntwriter.com and Tweets @huntwriter.
Buy New Design for Old Buildings, published by RIBA.

Advertisements